I’m on this thing called audioscrobbler, which is, I think, based in the UK. Basically, it provides an add-on to Winamp that tracks what I listen to on the computer, crunches some numbers, then provides me with graphs and piecharts to show me what I listen to.
It’s all done automatically, of course. The graphs and numbers are interesting, but where audioscrobbler provides an actual service is when it compares me to other people in the database, and then provides me with a list of users that listen to similar things, and a list of the bands and songs that they listen to. So I can check their graphs and pie-charts to find bands that I don’t listen to, but who maybe I should listen to, because I might like them.
I’m certain audioscrobbler isn’t the only service that does this. It’s just the one I stumbled onto.
So, over the last several months, I’ve been checking the site haphazardly to find new stuff, because I’m bored. During one of those checks, I noticed that audioscrobbler had provided all the information that I’d automatically divulged to Winamp to this other site, “last.fm.”
Finding this out filled me with dismay. I certainly hadn’t told audioscrobbler that they could willy nilly give my Winamp info out to third parties. It was outrageous! This was the exact reason why I’m so loathe to hand out any information on the net; in fact, I’ll surf past a site that requires cookies without a second thought. If it requires cookies, I don’t want to see it.
So, as I was screwing myself into the ceiling over this egregious breach of manners, I was checking out “last.fm.” They had everything that I had supplied audioscrobbler. Hell, they even had my login, not to mention the same password.
Of course, that’s a good thing and a bad thing.
It’s good in that (I realized) this site was controlled by the same people as the audioscrobbler site. It was, in fact, almost the same site, only with a different url and a slightly spiffier look.
It’s a bad thing because audioscrobbler didn’t tell me this was going to happen.
It’s a good thing because (I think) audioscrobbler isn’t sophisticated enough to know they gave the appearance of supplying my data to a third party.
It’s a bad thing because any web service provider should be sophisticated enough to know this.
In the end, it’s pretty egregiously bad, but innocent, and I like the content, so I let it slide. And to top it off, the port to ‘last.fm’ provides me, the user, with access to a radio metaphor that isn’t on audioscrobbler proper. So I get to click a button and listen to music that users who appear to like music that I like listen to.
That’s how I’m listening to Tomorrow Never Knows by the Beatles as I type, which is, in the end, a very good thing.